Tuesday, October 1, 2024

Benedict's Newsletter: No. 560

NO. 560   FREE EDITION   TUE 1 OCT 2024

In this issue: In this issue: Meta glasses, OpenAI dramas, Doomers lose in CA, Microsoft does nukes, and Apple is boring.

Read this issue as a web page. LINK

My Work

Competing in search

A quarter century after 'don't be evil' a judge has found that Google is abusing its monopoly in search. But no-one knows what happens next, and whether this ruling will change anything. Will Apple build a search engine? Will ChatGPT change search? Does it matter? LINK

Asking the wrong questions

With fundamental technology change, we don't so much get our predictions wrong as make predictions about the wrong things. LINK

News

Meta is still metaversing

Meta had a big event around VR and AR, announcing an updated Quest headset and a prototype of AR glasses, called 'Orion'. People who were at the event say the glasses are impressive, with a 70º field of view (FoV) and the compute in a wireless puck. 70º is a lot better than the 46º for Snap's dev kit announced last week (which doesn't have external compute), and the same as the Magic Leap 2 a few years ago (which did) but less bulky. However, this is still bulky and heavy by consumer standards, the resolution is very low, the battery lasts 2-3 hours… and the Orion isn't for sale - Meta says the production cost is around $10,000, which would require a retail price of $15-20k.

I haven't tried Orion, but I had a Magic Leap demo in Fort Lauderdale in September 2014, and compared the 'wow factor' to the iPhone - these devices feel like they must be part of the future, eventually. But here we are in 2024, with Meta showing us something still many years from being ready to sell. Apple is at least selling the Vision Pro, but it's effectively a dev kit that's also years for being ready for the mass market (which could mean Apple doesn't think it can get glasses to work). I wouldn't be surprised if Apple has something very similar to Orion in the lab, also for $10k and also years from being ready ready.

Meta has now spent well over $50bn on VR and AR research, partly because it thinks this will be the next universal device after the smartphones and partly because if it is, Zuck doesn't want someone else (i.e. Apple) to control it. The same goes for its investments in LLMs. But though the tech has got better since 2014, the questions haven't changed: how long until we have something normal people can use, and when we do, will they care? LINK, ANALYSIS

The week in OpenAI

OpenAI seems to have enough drama in a week to last an ordinarily respectable startup all its life. This week it rolled out its 'advanced voice' model (that one that supposedly sounded like Scarlett Johansson). Amusingly, its ability to sound enthusiastic or sad would make it technically illegal to use at work in the EU, since the AI Act (effective for next year) bans any AI product that can infer emotions. But meanwhile.. LINK

The CTO, Mira Murati, announced that she's leaving, along with both the Head and the VP of research. The board is considering ways to restructure the company into something more normal and rational, which might be a precondition of raising much more money. There was also a rumour that Sam Altman would be given 7% of the equity (he currently has zero), which he denied. DEPARTURES, ALTMAN EQUITY

The WSJ points out that Murati is one of more than 20 senior execs, researchers and co-founders who have quit this year. A lot of people don't seem to like working for Sam Altman. Alternatively, lots of other people can offer them real stock options (not 'Profit Participation Units') at real companies (see the Noam Shazeer story below). LINK

The NY Times has OpenAI financials, prepared as part of its current fund-raising. $300m monthly revenue in August and on track for $3.7bn in 2024, but $5bn of losses. It has 350m monthly active users (up from 100m in March) and 10m paying users. LINK

Seperately, the NY Times also reports that TSMC thought Sam Altman's "invest $7tr in AI chips" plan, reported earlier this year but never officially announced, was so ludicrous that they started calling him 'podcasting bro'. LINK

With all of this going on, it may or may not be a coincidence that the WSJ reports Apple is no longer looking at joining OpenAI's investment round or take a board observer seat. LINK

And finally, Sam Altman published an essay about the future of super-intelligence, which reads like a cross between a TED Talk and a sermon about The Rapture. I wonder who the intended audience is? LINK

California's governor vetoed its Doomer's Charter

California's governor vetoed an AI Safety bill, 'SB1047', which was pretty much a doomer's wish list, creating all sorts of onerous and impractical restrictions on AI development, including making anyone who makes an open source model liable for anything bad that anyone else did with it. This was by design: the people who originated the bill would be happiest if LLMs just didn't exist. There are broader stories about what kind of regulation of AI is a good idea (see below), and also about the failure of doomers to persuade many people outside their bubble, but today most of Silicon Valley will be relieved that something dumb and destructive didn't happen. LINK

Meanwhile, California passed a range of single-issue AI bills on things like deep fakes and using the voices of dead actors. In principle, I see this as the right approach. Trying to write one big law that controls anything anyone could do with AI is the wrong level of abstraction, just as it would be to regulate 'databases' or 'spreadsheets'. LINK

The week in AI

The WSJ confirmed that Google did a $2.7bn acquihire to bring back Noam Shazeer, a co-author of the transformers paper that kicked off the LLM boom, by 'licensing' tech from his new startup Character.ai. We seem to be repeating the war for AI talent of a decade ago, but at 100x the prices - he presumably made multiple 9 figures from this (?). LINK

Reddit will deploy AI-powered translation in dozens of new countries, 'flattening the world' as the saying goes. It was quite recent that machine translation was not very good and terrible outside a few target languages that got all of the investment - now it mostly 'just works', thanks to machine learning, and we are quickly taking it for granted. LINK

Microsoft is doing a deal to re-open a nuclear power plant to power a data centre. The power station in question is Three Mile Island, known for a famous though pretty minor accident in the 1970s. I am still getting used to hearing AI people talk about data centres in terms of gigawatts. Note, though, that while the models and the scale of their use are growing fast, the efficiency is increasing hugely - something between 75% and 90% efficiency gains in the last year or so, as the engineers took over from the scientists. LINK

Alibaba launched a new version of Qwen, its open source (sort of) family of LLMs, and it's at the top of the leaderboard for some benchmarks. LINK

US versus Chinese cars…

Apparently, the US is considering a ban on Chinese software and hardware in connected and autonomous vehicles. The new Chinese EV companies have better connected software than most traditional OEMs, and are doing pretty well in autonomy (and certainly driver-assist), so I can see the national security implications - you don't want China to be able to activate the microphone in selected vehicles (or, more dramatically, tell all the cars to stop, or all drive somewhere and crash into a target). But the electronics supply chain is so complex and interlocked that there will be be a lot of nuance to what exactly is banned. LINK

Huawei's triple-fold phone

Huawei was pushed out of the handset market by US sanctions a few years ago, but it wants to show that it's back, at least in China, with its own chips and its own OS (mostly an Android fork), and part of that means launching a flagship triple-folding phone, which it announced the day after Apple's annual iPhone event a few days ago. At a price of almost $3000, this is more a trophy (for both the customers and Huawei itself), and a statement of intent, that a competitive product. It weighs 50% more than an iPhone Pro, but has 3x the screen space, which is potentially interesting, but the folding screen still has the characteristic creases. We are still waiting for the 'right' folding screen device, but we are getting closer. LINK

About

What matters in tech? What's going on, what might it mean, and what will happen next?

I've spent 20 years analysing mobile, media and technology, and worked in equity research, strategy, consulting and venture capital. I'm now an independent analyst. Mostly, that means trying to work out what questions to ask.

Ideas

Google is using generative AI to design chips. LINK

A long and detailed analysis of how LLM agents could break down siloes between different enterprise software and make automation and integration easier. LINK

The two industries where generative AI is working first and fastest are programming and marketing (with customer support coming up behind) - this is a useful overview of how disruptive this could be to the advertising industry. LINK

Xavier 'Iliad' Niel, a French telecoms and internet mogul, is now on the board of TikTok. LINK

Roundup of the progress in Google's adtech competition trial. LINK

A lecture on the state of AI from Sundar Pichai. LINK

A Google security report on the wave of North Koreans with stolen identities acting as remote IT workers. LINK

We don't spend much time thinking about apps or smartphone platform wars anymore, but all the old issues are there - here the creator of the popular indie app IA Writer explains why Android is hard. LINK

Outside interests

The BBC's sound archive is online and free. LINK

Germans have installed half-a-million balcony solar panels. LINK

The scientific fraud problem. LINK

The glorious, historic European squares that were used for parking until recently LINK

Data

Bloomberg NEF produced a long study on electric trucks. LINK

The FT pulled Stripe data to find the AI starts have faster-growing renege than previous generations of startups. Interesting… except that given they have much higher marginal cost, they don't have a choice except to push for revenue as early as possible. LINK

Preview from the Premium edition

Apple is boring

There is something interesting, I think, in the general feeling in tech that this year's iPhones are entirely boring, when combined with this year's launch of 'Apple Intelligence', as Apple's first step in building generative AI. The old flattens out at the top of the S-Curve, just as the new thing starts to take off

Some part of this comes with a misunderstanding of the nature of hardware innovation - there is a view that the Orion glasses that Meta shows mean Meta is somehow ahead of Apple's Vision Pro. Yet neither of these is a product close to being ready. Meta has been building VR and AR in public for decades since buying Oculus, and now it shows something from the labs, that might ship in 5 or 10 years. Apple doesn't do concepts and prototypes: it has lots of things in the labs that we only see if and when they're ready (a huge car project, for example, that now we may never see). Indeed, the Vision Pro is very un-Apple-like not because it isn't ready, but because we're seeing it when it isn't ready. Hugo Barra called it an over-engineered dev kit. It's beautiful and it's an amazing demo, but, like the Orion, the Vision Pro, and indeed all AR and VR, is still years from being the kind of product that Mark Zuckerberg thinks could replace a smartphone. 

THIS IS A PREVIEW FROM THE PREMIUM EDITION - PREMIUM SUBSCRIBERS GET THE COMPLETE COLUMN EVERY WEEK. YOU SHOULD UPGRADE.
Upgrade to Premium
You're getting the Free edition. Subscribers to the Premium edition got this two days ago on Sunday evening, together with an exclusive column, complete access to the archive of over 500 issues, and more.
 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Have Coffee With Me Sunday Morning?

Sunday morning at 10 ET/9 CT/7 PT, I’ll be having coffee with my friend and former DOJ colleague Mary McCord and you’re invited to join us o...